Showing posts with label Prime Time. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Prime Time. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 05, 2006

O’Malley Must Go - Kenny

Enda Kenny told the Dáil (today) that he has no confidence in the Minister of State, Tim O'Malley, following the latter's comments on last night's Prime Time Investigates. He went on to call for the Taoiseach to seek Minister O'Malley's resignation over his handling of the services to patients with psychiatric illness and his grossly insensitive comments last night relating to waiting lists for such patients.

'Mental illness is devastating. It can tear families apart. That is why Fine Gael and Labour selected this issue as the first in a series of joint policy launches on the 5th of September this year. (See link to statement http://www.finegael.ie/news/index.cfm/type/details/nkey/29102/pkey/653/)

'Minister O'Malley's comments prove that he has no connection with those families. No warmth, no empathy, no understanding. He has had 4 ½ years to deliver services for the people that need them and he has failed to do so. Therefore, he is totally unsuited to the job. That is why the Taoiseach should seek his resignation.

'Mental illness is a private illness with very public consequences. When people's lives are collapsing around them, after ten years of FF and the PDs, they find they have no-one to turn to, nowhere to go. The Government has not addressed this crisis in ten years of record revenue. What makes anyone think they will do it in 15?

'The Minister is blaming everyone except himself. He is the Minister. The buck stops with him. Evading responsibility is now second nature to this dysfunctional Government. They have had nearly ten years in charge now. Six years ago the First Report of the Working Group on Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Services, set up by Minister Martin when he was Minister, said;

'It is recommended that a total of seven child and adolescent inpatient units for children ranging 6-16 should be developed throughout the country'

'Six years on and this commitment hasn't been delivered. Minister O'Malley has been in office for 4 ½ years of those 6 years and has clearly failed to deliver. This is in a period when the Government had booming tax revenues - €8,000 million more collected than expected in the last three years alone - and managed to throw money away on dud projects like PPARS, e-voting and the Bertie Bowl.

'Today there are 3,000 children waiting for psychiatric assessments with just 13 beds available to cater for their needs. In some cases these children are waiting for four and half years for an assessment - joining the waiting list at the time that Minister O'Malley took office. The HSE has clearly not substantiated Minister O'Malley's remarks about waiting lists and have left him isolated, save for the support of the Taoiseach who thinks Minister O'Malley is doing his best.

'Unfortunately, for patients with psychiatric illness Minister O'Malley clearly has no grasp or understanding of their circumstances. He may be doing his best, but his best falls miles short of what this under resourced and under appreciated sector needs. That is why he must go.'

Mentally ill children suffering from long-term Govt under funding – Neville

Fine Gael Deputy Health Spokesperson, Dan Neville TD, has said that the dismal response of the current Government to severely sub-standard child and adolescent psychiatric services, despite its unprecedented wealth, amounted to wholesale neglect. Deputy Neville added that unacceptably long waiting lists and the lack of in-patient places for young people, highlighted by the Prime Time programme, had tragically been evident for years.

'Last night's Prime Time programme starkly revealed the human suffering of those children and parents abandoned by Ireland's under-resourced psychiatric services. A deeply saddening exposé, it was unfortunately not surprising to those of us who have been working on mental health issues for some time.

'The fact is that child and adolescent psychiatric services account for only 5-10% of spending on mental health services, while serving 22.68% of the population. This under-investment has resulted, as we saw last night, in child and adolescent services which are either sporadic or non-existent.

'This situation has been allowed to develop despite the fact that in excess of 200,000 children have a mental or behavioural problem at any one time. The infrastructure is not in place to meet these needs and the lack of specialised services for young people has led to unacceptable long waiting lists and the admission of children into adult services.

'Hearing the personal stories of those young people last night who endured inappropriate accommodation in adult units was a gruelling experience and absolutely surreal in the context of 21st Century Celtic Tiger Ireland. It is absolutely galling to read that the current Government has taken in €8 billion more in taxes than expected in their own estimates and yet the State is still abandoning the most vulnerable of our citizens.

'Fine Gael, along with our colleagues in the Labour party, has committed to increasing specialist out-patient teams for child and adolescent services by 50% and to bringing the established teams up to the recommended staffing complement. In our first year of Government we will devote €16 million to child and adolescent services and we have committed to an €80 million programme over 5 years to increase in-patient facilities and achieve the target of comprehensive, fully staffed services for the specific needs of ADHD/hyperkinetic disorder and conduct disorder.

'In light of the very personal pain revealed in the Prime Time programme, the suffering of the children involved and the agony of parents whose children are either psychologically or physically being lost to them, the response of the Minister in charge of mental health services was deeply disappointing. Instead of casting about for scapegoats and calling for reviews when it's too late, the Minister should be apologising to those families who have been unable to find help despite their desperate need. Furthermore he should focus on completing those developments which are already underway as quickly as possible as well as following through on long-promised commitments.'