Showing posts with label Comment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Comment. Show all posts

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Lisbon - Round II

EU Flag + Gay UKImage by stephen.spillane via FlickrSo the stage is being set for us to vote on the EXACT same treaty again. Granted the only difference is that the member states will agree not to limit the number of EU Commissioners. The other changes will be copper fastening what we already have. A protocol on Abortion (Attached to Maastricht!), Military (Attached to Nice after Nice I) and Tax Sovereignty which is in all the treaties! Really come on like! How stupid do the government think we are? While I love Europe and the EU and all the good it does it, I am not voting for this treaty unless our Government and specifically our Taoiseach shows some leadership!

Martina Devlin has an excellent column in todays Indo on Brian Cowen's lack of leadership especially in comparison to Gordon Brown who "transformed himself into a phoenix among politicians, emerging gloriously from the ashes of his career after bold steps to tackle the banking meltdown". Which is true and opinion polls have shown that with a marked decline in the lead the Tories have over Labour.

The same cannot be said for Brian Cowen and Fianna Fail here. When ever there is an announcement all that follows is confusion and blame games. No one in this country will take the blame. When it was obvious to the dogs on the street that the Lisbon Referendum was going to fail, Brian Cowen decided to blame Fine Gael and Labour for not pulling their weight when it was obvious Fianna Fail TD's and suppporters where not canvassing (I didn't get canvassed by any 'Yes' group).

Though I am suppportive of the European Project, I am more supportive of Democracy and think unless there is substansive change to the treaty I shall be voting no.



Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Not in a Million Years!

Every time there is an election I always give Fianna Fail a look to see if I would give them a preference and next year in the Local's and Europeans a fairly high preference is on offer due to the fact there is only one FG candidate in Cork South Central LEA and Ireland Euro South constituency, but after yesterdays budget not in a million years will Fianna Fail get a preference, no matter how measly from me. The Greens and PD's (if they are still around) can go look somewhere else too, unless they get a backbone. Not only have FF lowered my take home pay by 1% (I'm on minimum wage ffs) but all my costs will rise because VAT is going up, road tax is going up, petrol is going, flights are going up among lots of other things (oh and wine, but not beer and spirits? would love to know the reasoning behind that). Also I see they are bring in College fees by stealth, increasing the registration fee by €500. this year the registration fee for UCC was €1050 (it was €750 when I started many moons ago (4)), so that lessens the likelihood of me returning to a HEI as I have to pay fees for the first two years.

The over 70's medical card is a scandal, it doesn't effect me personally but I do have elderly relations. It annoys me so much. I pity any one from FF or the Greens who knock on my door next year, as it's not only me who will be giving them a piece of my mind!

So FF/Greens, don't even bother asking me for a vote next year!

Sunday, September 21, 2008

Another opinion poll....

This time Ireland! Its an interesting one too.

The Party Breakdown is as follows

Fianna Fail 36% (down 4)
Fine Gael 28% (up 3)
Labour 9% (down 1)
Sinn Fein 9% (down 1)
Greens 7% (no change)
PD's 3% (up 1)

(June poll available here in PDF)

In another question in the poll 50% of people are not confident that the government can get the economy out of the current downturn.

Its nice to see FG up and FF down below the 40% (the polled 42% at the last General Election), also these polls are leading us into the local and european elections next year.

The PD's being up is a bit strange considering while the poll was being carried out, the leadership decided they were not politically viable. Then again the fact the PD's were in the media a lot over the grealish debacle raised their profile. But where will that 3% go is the question on everyone's lips?

More:
RTÉ Story - Poll shows fall in support for Fianna Fáil
Sunday Business Post - Sharp fall in support for Fianna Fáil as economy slumps
Irish Election - Fianna Fail Down in Business Post Poll

Monday, July 07, 2008

Me and Gay Marriage

Okay, so I get in a lot of trouble in gay circles and lefty equality circles (you know who you are Len) about my opposition or really lack of support for gay marriage.

I recently posted over on The Political Gay about my thoughts on the Heads of the Civil Partnership Bill 2008 (available here (PDF)).

Though I did take part in the LGBT Noise protest in Cork about the bill (Gaycork.com thread) I am not that fussed. I am broadly supportive of the bill and will be hoping it is passed more or less in its current state.

The one thing that made me turn up last week was the issue of adoption and children in general. It is completely ignored by the bill and I am not a happy bunny because of it. Of course, this might change in the future and maybe a second bill will allow gay adoption like what has happened in the UK. So I am adopting the Micheal Collins approach to this bill. For those of you unsure of that, I mean along the lines of what Collins said about the Anglo-Irish Treaty. It‘gives us the freedom, not the ultimate freedom that all nations desire and develop to, but the freedom to achieve it.’ I believe something similar about this bill, it will be a gradual thing, and as time goes by we will gain more rights and entitlements.

Now as for Marriage, I ain't a fan of it. Thats just who I am, to me its too religious and can never se myself have a Gay Civil Marriage. While Civil Partnership's I do support full heartedly and will be lobbying my Local TD's to support it with the minimum of amendments.

Sunday, June 15, 2008

Scouting - A New Program

A Langer's Blog has an excellent post on the upcoming Scouting Ireland National Council which will decide on a new program for Scouting in Ireland. He seams faily in favour of it, I'm not convinced. I don't like the way things are at the moment as there is no program and it leaves alot of us leaders in a very difficult poistion at times, so I'm willing to give the new program a go.

The one thing I am dissapointed with is the abolition of Macaoimh, well there has been no reference to it so far. I will state an interest here as I am Macaoimh Leader in the 37th Cork Group in Togher. The new age groups is one of the stumblimg blocks, the original proposal was

Tracker Scouts - 7-10 years
Explorer Scouts - 10-14 years
Discovery Scouts - 14-17 years
Rover Scouts - 17-21 years


This compares to the current system

Beavers - 6-8 years
Cubs/Macaoimh - 8-11 years
Scouts - 11-15 years
Venturers - 15-21 years


There was alot of concern about dropping the 6 year olds and there was alot of opposition within my own Group, so the National Management Committee has put forward an alternative proposal

Tracker Scouts - (6), 7, 8, (9) years
Explorer Scouts - (9), 10, 11, (12), (13) years
Discovery Scouts - (12), (13), 14, 15, (16), (17) years
Rover Scouts - (16), (17), 18, 19, 20, 21 years


Confused? Well it is a bit but this will allow groups to decide their own age ranges. I can see some groups trying to stick to the current system which I am told will be impossible as each section will be limited to three years.

My own scout county have decided we will harmonise our age ranges so that county events and competitions will be fair and will not have disparite ages. Which is something I hope most scout counties will do.

I have been involved in scouting since I joined Beaver Scouts when I was 6. I am glad that a new program is as this will allow scouting to develop and sustain in the future. So I hope the proposals do pass on later this month.

---
Orginal Post:
irish scout decision time - A Langers Blog

Links of Interest:
Scouting Ireland
Program 2008

Scouting Age groups from around the world
- Wikipedia

Saturday, June 14, 2008

Lisbon Round II? No Thanks!

I am getting very annoyed with certain leaders and pro-europeans on the European continent. Granted I was disappointed with the No vote but then again, I'm not surprised. It was very hard to sell and explain! And I had read the feckin thing! I still think that the EU needs reforming. Nice is not very satisfactory for me and we need reform, but not Lisbon. Its back to the drawing bored.

Certain EU leaders (Both Government and Opposition) seam to think its all right to ask us to vote again. I say NO! We had 55% turnout which is above average, we the people have spoken. The project must find another way to move forward.

If the government bows to pressure from France, Germany, Italy and others, I will not campaign for a Yes Vote, I infact will vote NO. If the EU is to be democratic then it should respect democratic outcomes.

People who read this blog know I am very pro-EU, infact nearly a Euro-federalist, but at the same time I respect the vote of the people. We in Ireland were in a unique position to vote on this treaty and we were not voting on it for 500 million other people, we were voting to change a document that says how Ireland is governed, Bunreacht na hEireann which only affects 4 million or so people. I am still annoyed with this arguement.

I have a big issue which the claims of some members of the No side. Sinn Fein did not win this for them In fact most people I talked to were ignoring SF. The people that won it were Libertas on the right and Coir (not sure where they are) and the sociailists and anarchists (People's movement) on the left who ran a very good campaign and were out in Cork City every weekend trying to convince people while the Yes crowd were no were to be seen.

Anyway I think I've made my point and my dinner is burning!

Saturday, October 20, 2007

Dumbledore is gay

Okay so now Damien's twitter makes sense :D

But while reading that article, I realise how much I hate Peter Tatchell! he actually said this

Gay human rights campaigner Peter Tatchell said: “It’s good that children’s literature includes the reality of gay people, since we exist in every society.

“But I am disappointed that she did not make Dumbledore’s sexuality explicit in the Harry Potter book.

“Making it obvious would have sent a much more powerful message of understanding and acceptance.”


Its a kids book for gods sake! This is why Section 28 was brought in and that! God that man drives me mad at times!

Skimmer Update

Well following may last post on skimmers it was on the front page of the Evening Echo (Im the Bank Customer) but it seams the Ulster Bank on Patrick St was also hit by the same people and people have been caught by that one.

So people beware


UPDATE: Front Page (PDF)

Tuesday, October 16, 2007

Twitterfeed set up

I have set up a Twitterfeed for this blog Steve My Opinion this goes alongside my personal twitter! :D Im getting around to lots of stuff today!

I wonder will it work the way I hope it will. I also had to sign up for OpenID for twitterfeed. Not sure what it does exactly...

Thursday, April 05, 2007

"Contract for a Better Ireland" Outdoor Media Campaign Launched by Fine Gael





The Fine Gael Leader, Enda Kenny T.D., today launched his Party's outdoor media campaign in support of his "Contract for a Better Ireland" which he set out in his Presidential speech at the Fine Gael Árd Fheis at the week-end. He was joined at the launch by Front Bench members Richard Bruton, Olivia Mitchell, Fergus O'Dowd and Dr Liam Twomey and first time Dáil candidates Leo Varadkar (Dublin West) and Lucinda Creighton (Dublin South East).

Commenting on the launch and the Contract for a Better Ireland, Enda Kenny said:

"At the week-end I set out my vision for a better Ireland. It is one based on ending the era of the broken promises and restoring the confidence the public have in their Government to deliver on their pledges. For too long we have seen empty promises reneged on by this Government and we now lie in the wreckage of their cavalier attitude to the public's interest.

"I am confident that the Contract for a Better Ireland will help restore the public's faith in the political process. I have set out an agenda, the fundamental building blocks of a better Ireland, that I will deliver on when elected Taoiseach. Only after having delivered on this Contract will I seek re-election as Taoiseach. If I have not, I will not.

"Today's launch highlights two key components of the Contract - health and crime. There are four different posters highlighting specific commitments from the Contract that will be running over the coming weeks, and they are:

Poster 1 "Free health insurance for all children under 16."
Poster 2 "2,300 more hospital beds."
Poster 3 "Tougher sentences, tougher bail for criminals."
Poster 4 "2,000 more Gardaí on the streets."

"The campaign will incorporate a mixture of 48 sheet posters, a heavy concentration on 6 sheet posters (bus shelters etc), targeted print media, transport media and online advertising.

"Over the coming weeks the public have a choice to make. Will they continue with the cycle of broken promises and empty rhetoric of the past 10 years, or will they sign up for the Contract for a Better Ireland? I am growing more confident with each passing day that the public will sign up for the Contract, they will vote for accountable politics and they will vote for Fine Gael."


I think they are good posters they are strong, attract attention and look good.

Monday, March 05, 2007

Response to Crticisim - Update on Head to Head

Well I had a look over at the Irish times head to head, and I noticed someone and taken issue, with my post.


This guy Stephen said

Read comments with interest. I come down on balance with the No, because the arguments for gay/lesbian adoption amount in my view to a campaign for parental rights over (but of course not necesarily in contradiction with) child welfare. But open to be persuaded. One question I would like to put is to those who say "sexual orientation should never be an issue". I am not saying this should be the only issue, but surely it is an issue, just as race is an issue in adoption. Adoption agencies usually prefer to place children with parents of the same race if possible, but of course do not stick dogmatically to this, there being many considerations. Why are you so sure it should not be an issue? Is there a "because...." or is it a necessary dogma of the position, just as the religious right would say "the bible says..."?
Mr. Spillane is wrong I beleive to think he can adopt as a single man (gay or straight). As far as I understand it, you simply won't be able to adopt here as a single person, male or female. Am I wrong?


and

again, emily spillane conjoins two unconnected points. "There are many bad straight parents"+ "gay/lesbian people should be able to adopt". The former does not support the conclusion.
There have to be better arguments that these? At least Kieran Healy addresses the issue, claiming that homosexual couples can provide [a safe and supportive atmosphere] as well as any other couple and better than a care home." I have to wonder though, in the case where two equally happy caring couples, one straight and one homosexual, were seeking to adopt a child, who should the child go to? Would it not be true to say that placing the child with the straight couple would make for a more normal childhood, and thus be in the better interests of the child?


My Response

Stephen, Yes at the moment a single gay man i can adopt, there is nothing in legislation to stop this. If an Bord Uachtála think I would make a good parent in my current circumstances I can adopt and/or foster. Anyway, I can have a child if I wish, just cause I'm gay does not mean I am infertile. I know of many gay men who are fathers, and are brilliant father who shower love and attention on their children. Is that so wrong?

There is no data to support the claim that children raised by married gay parents fare worse than those raised by heterosexual ones,.... That's why almost every serious child welfare entity, including the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Child Welfare League of America and the American Psychological Association, recognizes that gay parents are no worse than heterosexual ones. (Source The Washington Post http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03/10/AR2006031002031.html)

You also claim that placing the child in a straight relationship, in resposne to Emily Spillane's post, would have a more normal childhood, but I ask you what is a normal childhood, I do not think for one moment I had a normal childhood, I had a fantastic childhood, with parents who showered me with love and attention, and I believe had I been brought by a homosexual couple, I would have had the same!

A major part of this which you seam to be ignoring is the problem of Gay/Lesbian parents face, what if something happens to one of them, one of them is in the eyes of the law, a starnger to the child. This cannot be good for a relationship as it puts a strain on it and proves that Gay/Lesbian parents have to put alot of thought into having a child, that most straight couples wouldn't have to.


The poll so far has yes at 86% and no's at 14%.

Head2Head on Gay Adoption

i just got an email about this, the Irish Times has a head to head on Gay Adoption on their website today. Head over and voice your opinion! I'll post up my comment once it appears

Catherine Egan-Morley argues yes, she lives in Co Cork and is executive director of the independent social policy consultancy agency Clarity: Research, Development and Training.


Tom O'Gorman argues no, he is a researcher at the Iona Institute.

I was torn on this issue till lately, so wait for my comment!

**UPDATE** My comment!

As a young gay man, I look forward to a time, when my circumstances allow me to settle down and raise children. I don't see the difference between me and my sister. She can adopt as a straight women, and I can adopt leagally in Ireland as a single gay man, but if I'm in a relationship I'm not allowed. This is a very starnge analomy in Irish law. This needs to be earsed and all people regardless of sexuality, if they are capable of giving a child a loving home, as that what is important should be allowed to adopt, single, gay, straight, bisexual, whatever!


My mothers comment!! I love my mum!!!

There are many 'straight' people who do not make good parents. Everyone should be elegible to adopt a child - sexual orientation should not come into the equation.

Monday, February 19, 2007

A reduction in the top rate of tax helps those on low income - wtf???????

Sam over at Pull Out The Pin in his PD Conference reaction post claims the following

The tax cuts are terrific, as I am a supply-sider and am firmly convinced that reductions in the upper rate benefit people on lower incomes profoundly


Now I must say that is news to me. I left a comment on his blog saying

How can a lower upper rate benefit those on low incomes. I speak from a family in the lower band that the tax cuts introduced in the last budget on the upper tax band did nothing to help us. I just dont get it, it only helps the rich, those paying the top rate. The Labour proposal will help us, but the PD proposals will not


So here's my scenario. I'm on the lower tax band, earning €30,000 a year, and the PD's go ahead and reduce the top rate of tax to 38% and increase the tax band to €50,000. How does it help me?

It dosent on the other hand, here's another scenario a I'm a single person €60,000 a year, current €34,000 of this is taxed and at 21% and the remainder (€26,000) is taxed at 41%. So if the PD's go ahead and reduce the top rate of tax to 38% and increase the Standard Rate Cut Off Point €50,000, I'm singing and dancing in the street.

So how does it help people on low incomes Sam?


All tax information taken from the Citizens Information Website

Sunday, February 18, 2007

ESB considers the nuclear option!?

What? huh? where? when?

Via Breakingnews

The ESB has indicated its interest in entering the nuclear power market.

The company's chairman told the Sunday Business Post newpaper that he would consider a joint venture with one of the bigger European energy companies.

The Government is currently opposed to nuclear power, however Tadhg O'Donoghue says he believes their stance will have to change over the next number of years.


Can't really see any government sanctioning this considering the Irish opposition to Sellafield. Stupid ESB. Consider away, it wont happen. Christy will get the guitar out again!

Friday, February 16, 2007

Recommendations for Ireland in the EU Parliament report

following on from the Morning Briefing this morning here are the recommendations for Ireland.

IRELAND

121. Welcomes the testimony given to the Temporary Committee by the Irish Minister for Foreign Affairs on behalf of the Irish Government as well as his unequivocal criticism of the process of extraordinary rendition; notes the fact, however, that he failed to answer all the questions in relation to the concerns that Irish airports may have been used by CIA aircraft travelling to or from extraordinary rendition missions (as in the case of Abu Omar);

122. Thanks the Irish Human Rights Commission (IHRC) for its testimony to the Temporary Committee and endorses its view which considers that acceptance by the Irish government of diplomatic assurances do not fulfil Ireland's human rights obligations, which oblige the government actively to seek to prevent any actions that could in any way facilitate torture or ill-treatment in Ireland or abroad; regrets the decision of the Irish Government not to follow the IHRC's advice on this matter to date; notes that there is continuing dialogue between the IHRC and the Irish Government;

123 Changed at plenary. Notes the 147 stopovers made by CIA-operated aircraft at Irish airports and expresses serious concern about the purpose of those flights which came from or were bound for countries linked with extraordinary rendition circuits and the transfer of detainees. Deplores the stopovers in Ireland of aircraft which have been shown to have been used by the CIA, on other occasions, for the extraordinary rendition of Bisher Al-Rawi, Jamil El-Banna, Abou Elkassim Britel, Khaled El-Masri, Binyam Mohammed, Abu Omar and Maher Arar and for the expulsion of Ahmed Agiza and Mohammed El Zari.

124. Notes the absence of Irish parliamentary scrutiny of either Irish or foreign intelligence services and the potential that this creates for abuse;

125. Considers, that, in the absence of a system of random searches, a ban should be imposed on all CIA-operated aircraft landing in Ireland;

126. Urges the Irish Government, in view of the findings of the Temporary Committee, to agree to launch a parliamentary inquiry into the use of Irish territory as part of the CIA rendition circuit.


(Source)

I never realised that Dáil Eireann has no powers of scrutiny over Irish let alone foreign intelligence services!

I agree with the ban on all CIA flights trough Ireland and I believe their should be a parliamentary inquiry into and that the Irish Human Rights Commission be called to give evidence before it, as the have long-held that the flights were happening and illegal.

FYI the report was approved by a majority of 382 against 256 with 74 abstentions.

Sunday, February 11, 2007

My Opinion nominated for Best News/Current Affairs Blog at the Irish Blog Awards

OMG!!!! am soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo in shock!! Huge thanks to Sam for pointing out that i was nominated!! I'm just delighted to be nominated! If people wish to vote for me please do at the awards site and you will find the nomination under Best News/Current Affairs Blog and the name is Stephen Spillane.

I need a moment... wasn't expecting this at all

Thursday, February 01, 2007

Morning Briefing, 1st February

Dia Duit!!!

First one in awhile I know, but have been busy with campaign stuff!

Dáil seats for NI MP's (Breakingnews) I personnally disagree with them having anything to do with the Dáil as they were elected to Westminster not Dáil Eireann.

France implements its smoking ban (Breakingnews). Woooo! There are now calls for a European wide ban, which i believe would be a goo idea.

Ad causes caos in Boston (BBC)Jaysus, some people take things too far in their reaction! they look harmless like!!

Herouxville, Canada has posted on its website what immigrants are not too do (BBC)

"We consider it completely outside norms to... kill women by stoning them in public, burning them alive, burning them with acid, circumcising them etc."

It points out that women are allowed to drive, vote, dance and own their own homes


You got to love the Canadians!

Israel had developed a Flying car!!! (CNN)Excellent idea!!!!!!

Thats all for now, have a good day!!!

Monday, January 15, 2007

"Color-coded causes"

Via PersonalizedCause.com

When Chris Vance, the chairman of the state Republican Party, pinned on an orange ribbon during a rally opposing the confirmation of Christine Gregoire as Washington's governor, he could have been signaling his support for cultural diversity, calling attention to the tragedy of world hunger or taking a stand against lupus.

He was doing none fo these, of course.

Vance and several other Republican lawmakers wore orange ribbons to make the connection between this state's close gubernatorial contest and the fraudulent Ukrainian election that resulted in nationwide protests last fall. In November, supporters of opposition candidate Viktor Yushchenko took to the strees of Kiev en masse, waving banners and the orange flags of his party.

"There's a real sense that what happened in the Ukraine happened here," Vance said in a recent phone intervview. About the protests and the subsequent second election in that nation, Vance said, "We're hoping we can do the same thing here, in a more civilized fashion.".

Whether or not Vance and his fellow protesters, many of whom bore orange balloons, succeed in getting the revote they desire, they will certainly have sent a message, even if it wasn't a clear one at first glance. With the increasing identification of colors with political or social causes, it's a challenge to find a color that hasn't been adopted by one organization or another.

"We're using color coding and color symbolism now to an extent we never have," said Margaret Walch, director of the New York-based Color Asssociation of the United States, a nearly 90-year old color forecasting organization. The facts would seem to bear her out: Almost every color has multiple causes.

More than 500 years ago, England was racked by a 30-year civil war between the House of Lancaster, represented by a red rose, and the House of York, represented by a white rose. A similar contemporary polarity might be the concept of the red and blue states, an entirely media-created visual metaphor - neither party has officially embraced red or blue as its defining color, according to Republican Vance and Paul Berendt, the chairman of the state Democratic Party.

Like the red state/blue state phenomenon, many of American culture's most well-knwon color-cause associations have risen to prominence only in recent history:

THE YELLOW MILITARY RIBBON
Perhaps the oldest of the bunch, the yellow ribbon (seen these days on cars and bedecking the I-5 overpass near Fort Lewis in support of faraway soldiers) can trace its history back at least 50 years.

The Library of Congress's American Folklife Center uncovered a folk tale from that time telling of a released convict whose family was to tie a ribbon to a tree in their front yard as a way of letting him know whether or not they wanted him back.

That tale morphed into the popular 1970s song "Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round the Ole Oak Tree," which inspired Penne Laingen to do just that in her yard in 1979 as a symbol of hope that her husband, Ambassador Bruce Laingen, held during the Iraninan hostage crisis, would return home safely. Thus, a national craze was spawned. The folklife center's Web site notes that there's no real evidence to support the commonly held believe that the yellow ribbon has its roots in the Civil War.

THE RED HIV/AIDS RIBBON
In 1991, an offshoot of New York organization Visual AIDs decided to create a symbol to indicate support for people living and coping with AIDS and HIV.

Capitalizing on the popularity of the yellow-ribbon campaign backing soldiers serving in the first Iraq war, the group decided on a red ribbon, to indicate "passion - not only anger, but love, like a valentine," according to Visual AIDS' Web site.

Actor Jeremy Irons wore a red AIDS ribbon while hosting the 1991 Tony Awards ceremony, pusing the symbol into the limelight and making it a cultural icon.

THE PINK BREAST CANCER RIBBON
This can be traced to the early '90s as well, according to the national organization Breast Cancer Action, when 68-year-old Charlotte Haley began distributing handmade peach-colored ribbons and urging people to wear them to "wake up our legislators and America" to the need for more cancer funding.

Soon after, Estee Lauder and Self magazine came knocking, hoping to use Haley's ribbon, but she refused on the grounds that they were too commercial. Of course, that merely meant that Lauder and Self would create their own ribbon, the current pink one, chosen because the color is "soothing, comforting and healing"; Haley's peach ribbon was soon forgotten.

Those overwhelmed by the rainbow of colored ribbons might do well to ask, "Why color? Why now?"

The Color Association's color-devoted director, Walch, has a partial answer: "Color is the first thing you see..It's often used as an identification for people you don't know, because it's so visible. Any color has high visibility."

That might seem self-evident, but it's worth considering. In this age of information overload, colors provide a simple, easy-to-parse identifier for a message.

All it takes is one look to see and understand a red ribbon. But things are more complicated now that several causes are connected with many colors. The only recourse is inventiveness. For instance, to show support for those coping with autism, pin on a multicolored jigsaw-puzzle ribbon (the puzzle represents the complex mystery of the condition).


Old story i know, but good points raised in it!

Saturday, January 13, 2007

Excellent video from MSNBC



Found the above on a friends bebo!!! Tis excellent!

Monday, January 08, 2007

Should smokers be refused surgery?


Last year a NHS primary care trust announced it would take smokers off waiting lists for surgery in an attempt to contain costs.

The BMJ have two very interesting articles on this.

On the Yes side; Matthew J Peters, associate professor, Department of Thoracic Medicine, Concord Repatriation General Hospital, Concord NSW 2139 Australia;
argues that denying operations is justified for specific conditions

On the No side; Leonard Glantz, professor of health law, bioethics, and human rights, Boston University School of Public Health, 715 Albany Street, Boston, MA 02118, USA; believes it is unacceptable discrimination

The Yes arguements

(Full Article)

Failure to quit smoking before certain elective procedures confers such clinical detriment that to proceed to surgery is ill judged.


Wow, straight off the bat, Peters sets out his opposition.

Smoking up to the time of any surgery increases cardiac and pulmonary complications, impairs tissue healing, and is associated with more infections and other complications at the surgical site. These adverse effects compromise the intended procedural outcomes and increase the costs of care.


This is a good reason, but I'm slow to support cost as an issue, as no cost should be spared in saving someones life.

Such a policy should be limited to procedures where the evidence of harm is strongest. These include plastic and reconstructive surgery and some orthopaedic surgery. A study of experimental sacral incisions of 12-18 mm found that infection occurred in 12% of smokers and 2% of non-smokers. Infection rates in smokers who had quit for four weeks were similar to those in non-smokers. In a study of wound and other complications after hip or knee arthroplasty, no smoker who quit developed a wound infection compared with 26% of ongoing smokers and 27% of those who simply reduced tobacco use. Overall complications were reduced to 10% in those who quit smoking compared with 44% in those who continued.


here, Peters has good reasoning for the refusal in surgery, but at the same time limits it to certain procedures.

With arthroplasty, some of the wound infections were limited to erythema, but 13% of smokers required re-operation because of infection. Such infections have been shown to prolong total hospital stay, double readmission rates, and quadruple costs of orthopaedic surgery. This represents a 38% increase in the direct cost of care for each smoker having surgery. In the arthroplasty study the intervention group had an average length of hospital stay of 14 rather than 11 days.


So in other words, you smoke and have an operation, you will be in hopsital longer. Again cost is being brought in, but dont smokers pay enough tax, so they deserve the treatment?

Increased use of hospital beds and associated costs mean less opportunity to treat other patients. Based on these data, five non-smokers could be operated on for the cost and bed use of four smokers and the non-smokers' surgical outcomes would be better. A well informed smoker, unwilling or unable to quit, might assume an increased risk for himself, but the decision is not his alone when it can indirectly affect others. Then, the community must involve itself.


Here the fact that 4 non-smokers could be treated in the time it takes to treat a smoker, Peters attempts to make it a community issue.

With surgery that is done for purely cosmetic purposes, the increase in the risk and consequences of wound infection or fat necrosis from smoking is unacceptable and surgery is illogical


Here I assume, the surgery is private as it is cosmetic, that the extra cost will be borne by the patient.

The No Arguments

(Full article)

One of the noblest things about the profession of medicine has been its single minded devotion to patients. Doctors routinely treat patients who are despised by the society in which they live—enemy troops, terrorists, murderers. Given this, it is astounding that doctors would question whether they should treat smokers.


Glentz is straigvht off with the hipocratic oath, seams to me he has the upper groud from the start due to this.

Tobacco companies used to win every lawsuit brought against them by diseased smokers because they successfully argued that smokers knowingly and voluntarily assumed the risks of smoking—if smokers do not want to incur the well known risks of smoking they should simply stop.

But the 1988 US Surgeon General's report on the addictive nature of cigarette smoking gave plaintiffs' lawyers a way to rebut this argument.1 Smokers could now be portrayed as enslaved by the tobacco companies and incapable of stopping smoking because of their addiction. As a result, smokers did not voluntarily incur the risk of smoking but rather did so involuntarily because of their addiction. It is not without some irony that surgeons who refuse to perform operations on patients unless they stop smoking make the same argument that cigarette companies used—if smokers don't want to incur the adverse effects of smoking, including refusal of surgery, they should quit.


wow, huge rubuking of surgeons here, comparing them with tobacco companies if they refuse to carry out surgery. He has a point though. Glentz refers to the Surgeon General's 1988 report which should also force the doctors to carry out these operations.


Assuming we can accurately determine who falls into the class of smoker (is it someone who smokes 40 cigarettes a day, 10 a day, or the occasional cigar?), the idea of doctors treating all smokers the same way runs directly counter to the practice of medicine. This requires an individualised evaluation of each patient to determine the appropriateness of a treatment regimen. Evidence exists that smokers are at an increased risk of postsurgical complications compared with non-smokers, and when smokers stop smoking before surgery their risks of complications decrease. But those same data show that most smokers who have surgery have no complications, and a policy denying all smokers access to surgical procedures arbitrarily denies beneficial treatment to those who would have had no complications.


Here Glentz realy goes in for the kill, how do you define a smoker? Some smokers wont get infections, so maybe you wont treat 4 non-smokers in the same time-frame

Withholding surgery from smokers also distorts the modern doctor-patient relationship, which is based on partnership. Doctors determine the risks and benefits of treatment, inform the patients of these facts, and patients then decide whether to incur the risks to gain the benefits. This applies equally to smokers and non-smokers. Doctors should certainly inform patients that they might reduce their risks of postsurgical complications if they stop smoking eight weeks before the procedure. There is every reason to believe many patients would follow their doctors' advice. The question is, "Should the price of not following the doctor's advice be the denial of beneficial surgery?" Should someone who was crippled by arthritic knee pain be denied surgery because she would knowingly and willingly take an increased risk of incurring postsurgical complications? If the decision whether to take an increased risk is not left to patients, they are likely to lie to their doctors about their smoking. This deception, of course, will make us unable to help smokers who wish to stop but fear the repercussions of disclosing their smoking to their doctors.


Most people value the doctor-patient relationship due to confidentiality etc, so if you cannot trust your doctor that he will operate on you because you are a smoker, why trust him?

An argument made to support the discriminatory non-treatment of smokers is that increased complications lead to additional expenditures that could be avoided if smokers would simply stop smoking. But why focus our cost saving concerns on smokers in the context of surgery? Do patients have a general obligation to get healthy as a condition of receiving treatment? Patients are not required to visit fitness clubs for eight weeks, lose 25 pounds, or take drugs to lower blood pressure before surgery.

Many non-smokers cost society large sums of money in health care because of activities they choose to take part in. "Baby boomers" in the United States lost 488 million days of productivity in 2002 because of sports injuries. From 1991-8 sports related injuries in this age group increased 33% and cost about $18.7bn (£9.6bn; 14bn) a year in medical costs alone.3 We could reduce healthcare expenditure by simply refusing to pay for treating any injuries related to voluntary participation in sports. Let them suffer their painful knee condition which is entirely their fault. Indeed, if we treat a sports injury that person is likely to risk incurring future costly sports injuries. But we don't even think this let alone suggest it.


Here is a great arguement for ignoring the cost arguement and i agree completely.

Discriminating against smokers has become an acceptable norm. Indeed, at least one group of authors who believe smokers should be refused surgery blithely admits that it is "overtly discriminatory."4 The suggestion that we should deprive smokers of surgery indicates that the medical and public health communities have created an underclass of people against whom discrimination is not only tolerated but encouraged. When the World Health Organization announced that it would no longer employ anyone who smokes, public health and medical communities did not respond to this act of blatant bigotry.5 6 Similarly, it is shameful for doctors to be willing to treat everybody but smokers in a society that is supposed to be pluralistic and tolerant. Depriving smokers of surgery that would clearly enhance their wellbeing is not just wrong—it is mean.


In the final paragraph Glentz puts the nail in the coffin. Discrimination. Though not mentioned, under Article 1 of Protocol no. 12 of the European Convention of Human Rights

1. The enjoyment of any right set forth by law shall be secured without discrimination on any ground such as sex, race, colour, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, association with a national minority, property, birth or other status.

2. No one shall be discriminated against by any public authority on any ground such as those mentioned in paragraph 1.

Source

The NHS is a public authority so therfore I assume that smoking would come under 'other status' as it is a choice, or addiction. It is not tested in the European Court of Human Rights but it would be an interesting case.

I think the No side wins this arguement. well its the side I agree with.