Showing posts with label Treaty of Lisbon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Treaty of Lisbon. Show all posts

Saturday, December 13, 2008

There is something that might get me to vote yes

Signing the Treaty of NiceImage via WikipediaI know I have stated before that I will vote no to Lisbon if it is put again to the electorate (here and here) but a post over on Slugger reminds me why I should vote yes.

The Nice Treaty.

I hated that treaty and when it comes to being a choice, as José Manuel Barroso said "We have either one Treaty or the other Treaty" and when it comes to me picking I prefer the Lisbon Treaty.

Under the Nice we lose our commissioner, as I pointed out during the campaig. Under Libon this might not happen and looks like it won't happen if they agree before hand. But under Lisbon if we do lose the commissioner it is under a lot fairer system especially in comparison to the system under Nice where one country loses out.

Voting, under Nice the arrangements are as follos for a proposal in the EU Council.
For a proposal to pass it needs the majority of countries (50% or 67%) and votes (74%) and population (62%). For a proposal to fail a condition to pass a vote must not be achieved. Under Lisbon the procedure is much easier, firstly to understand and secondly to block. The proposed method for a proposal to pass is a majority of countries (55% or 72%) representing 65% of the population or a condition to block not met. For a proposal to fail at least four countries must be against the proposal. In cases where, under the Treaties, not all members participate the minimum number of members representing more than 35% of the population of the participating Member States, plus one member are against the proposal. The second condition of at least 4 countries against the proposal is to ensure that the most populous Member States cannot block decisions and is important in 10 different voting scenarios where legislation requiring QMV can be passed although the population requirement isn't fulfilled and all member states except:

#Germany and France and one of UK, Italy, Spain or Poland
#Germany and UK and one of Italy, Spain or Poland
#Germany and Italy and one of Spain or Poland
#France and UK and Italy

are for the proposal. Which means the larger states cannot block passage of proposals.

Nice, in my opinion, was not a good deal for small member states and I was against it. Lisbon on the other hand is a fairer deal and I was for it. I am going to have a lot of wrangling with myself over how I will vote next year. Only time will tell if I can change how I will vote.



Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Some tips for Brian Cowen

european union coloursImage by friendly-fire via FlickrFionnan Sheahan had an excellent column in yesterdays Indo on how Cowen et al could actually pass Lisbon the 2nd time round. I have to agree with him on most of his points.

1 Read the "bloody" Treaty.
This was a major one. Something I came across on the canvass and considering I actually read the treaty, its not impossible. But of course Cowen is not the only one, Mary Coughlan also needs classes on EU basics, especially the commission.

2 The Green Party, the IFA and SIPTU need to back the treaty from the start.
The Green Party because they are in Government! The IFA will probably back it because of the pork debacle and that. SIPTU need to be given reassurances on their issues, but it needs to be done behind the scenes not in public.

3 The same blood, sweat and tears put into a general election is needed to canvass for votes in this referendum.
That is something that every party is at fault for. Labout putting up posters with small yes'. FG putting focus on Enda and the MEPs. FF for not doing much canvassing. All sides need to convince their supporters and make sure they are well briefed to deal with questions.

4 Give people a reason to vote Yes
Anyone could write reams on why to vote no, but the yes arguments never stuck. This is something they need to work on.

5 It's the economy, stupid
Europe is in a recession, can we face it better as a group which might lessen the effects of that terrible budget? Its a "twin-edged sword" which is mainly the fault of the Government.

6 Run your own campaign has to be the message for the political parties.
FF and FG should not be co-operating too much in the public eye. FF and Greens working together and FG and Labour working together is natural. But all the parties doing a united campaign won't wash it.

7 Tighten up funding laws
This will lower the hassle after the vote if another "libertas" type group crops up.

8 No own goals
Can the government stop making stupid moves? I don't know. But it will be critical if the Government want to get this passed.

9 Challenge the No camp claims
A lot of time was spent trying dispel "myths". Try challenging them to back up their claims and people will see the truth.

10 A coherent Yes campaign wouldn't actually go astray
Okay so dont work in public but work together behind the scene. No point in replicating work, and that it just wastes time and resources.

11 Reach out to reassure specific groups
Certain groups had certain issues, no harm in targetting them.

12 Stop patronising people
Convince them! Dont tell them what to do.

13 Speak plain language
In other words, dont tell Brsin go off on his trip to jargon-land. The EU is confusing enough, with out using obscure and strange terminology.

Anything else you add?



Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Lisbon - Round II

EU Flag + Gay UKImage by stephen.spillane via FlickrSo the stage is being set for us to vote on the EXACT same treaty again. Granted the only difference is that the member states will agree not to limit the number of EU Commissioners. The other changes will be copper fastening what we already have. A protocol on Abortion (Attached to Maastricht!), Military (Attached to Nice after Nice I) and Tax Sovereignty which is in all the treaties! Really come on like! How stupid do the government think we are? While I love Europe and the EU and all the good it does it, I am not voting for this treaty unless our Government and specifically our Taoiseach shows some leadership!

Martina Devlin has an excellent column in todays Indo on Brian Cowen's lack of leadership especially in comparison to Gordon Brown who "transformed himself into a phoenix among politicians, emerging gloriously from the ashes of his career after bold steps to tackle the banking meltdown". Which is true and opinion polls have shown that with a marked decline in the lead the Tories have over Labour.

The same cannot be said for Brian Cowen and Fianna Fail here. When ever there is an announcement all that follows is confusion and blame games. No one in this country will take the blame. When it was obvious to the dogs on the street that the Lisbon Referendum was going to fail, Brian Cowen decided to blame Fine Gael and Labour for not pulling their weight when it was obvious Fianna Fail TD's and suppporters where not canvassing (I didn't get canvassed by any 'Yes' group).

Though I am suppportive of the European Project, I am more supportive of Democracy and think unless there is substansive change to the treaty I shall be voting no.



Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Friday, September 26, 2008

A possible solution?

Again and again Lisbon raises it head. I was at an FG Branch meeting last week when an idea for a solution to Lisbon was aired. Split in three was the suggestion. The three sections would be:

1. The institutional reform part of the treaty

2. The Charter for Fundamental Rights

3. The Common Foreign and Security Policy


Now that should make things a bit easier and you split the argument in 3 and means those who know the EU needs reforming but who have doubts on CFSP and on the Charter can vote no to them. The UK and Poland have secured opt-outs on the Charter and Denmark has long held opt-outs (from Amsterdam or Maastricht) on CFSP.

Of course I would vote Yes to all 3 and would be encouraging people to vote YES-YES-YES.

Decisions are going to have to be made soon and if the Government put the same question again, I wont be supporting it.


----
Lisbon Round II? No Thanks!

Sunday, July 20, 2008

Treaty of Lisbon, State of Play: 20th July

So it's been awhile since I've done this but Europe seams to be pressing ahead with ratification despite the Irish 'No' Vote. I have changed the layout slightly to show ratifications as some states have passed the treaty but have not ratified it.

Austria - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 24/04/2008. Ratified: 13/5/2008

Belgium - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 10/07/2008

Bulgaria - Parliamentary Vote. Approved 21/3/2008. Ratified : 28/04/2008

Cyprus - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 03/07/2008

Czech Republic - Parliamentary Vote. Court Case delaying the vote

Denmark - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 24/04/2008. Ratified : 29/05/2008

Estonia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 11/06/08

Finland - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 11/06/08

France - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/02/2008. Ratified : 14/02/2008

Germany - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 23/05/08 Court Case delaying Ratification

Greece - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 11/06/08

Hungary - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 17/12/2007. Ratified : 06/02/2008

Republic of Ireland - Referendum. Not approved : 12/06/08

Italy - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress.

Latvia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/05/2008. Ratified : 16/06/2008

Lithuania - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/05/2008

Luxembourg - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 29/05/08

Malta - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 29/01/2008. Ratified : 06/02/2008.

Netherlands - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/07/2008

Poland - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 02/04/2008. President withholding ratification till Ireland ratify's the treaty.

Portugal - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 23/04/2008. Ratified : 17/06/2008

Romania - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 04/02/2008. Ratified : 11/03/2008

Slovakia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 10/04/2008. Ratified : 24/06/2008

Slovenia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 29/01/2008. Ratified : 24/04/2008

Spain - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 15/07/2008

Sweden - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in November.

United Kingdom - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 19/06/2008. Ratified : 16/07/2008

--
Sources:
Wikipedia
Europa

Friday, June 20, 2008

"no alternative to a new referendum"

From todays Indo


TAOISEACH Brian Cowen has been given a year by his European counterparts to push through a second referendum on the Lisbon Treaty, the Irish Independent has learned.

EU leaders yesterday firmly ruled out a renegotiation of the treaty as a way to resolve the crisis caused by Ireland's 'No' vote last week.

Government sources said it was also made clear that there was no alternative to a new referendum.


I am very annoyed!!! 55% of people eligible to vote turned up to vote on June 12th and the majority said "NO".

Though I was supporting a "Yes" vote during the campaign, if EU leaders are adamant that we vote on this treaty without changes then I will vote NO on the second go round.

I want a Europe that is democratic and transparent. This is not how we get it! Ignoring the democratic will of the Irish people will not endear Europe to us.

When France and the Netherland voted "NO" there voices were respected. Why aren't ours?

Some during the referendum claimed a "No" vote would lead to a two tier Europe. What the vote has shown is that there IS a two tier Europe, One Europe of core founding and large states and one of late comers on the periphry.

This is not a fair Europe.

This outcome has actually led me to become quite Eurosceptic which is strange considering I do support a united Europe....

Time to go rethink where I stand....

Orginally Posted on The Political Gay over on GayCork.com

Saturday, June 14, 2008

Lisbon Round II? No Thanks!

I am getting very annoyed with certain leaders and pro-europeans on the European continent. Granted I was disappointed with the No vote but then again, I'm not surprised. It was very hard to sell and explain! And I had read the feckin thing! I still think that the EU needs reforming. Nice is not very satisfactory for me and we need reform, but not Lisbon. Its back to the drawing bored.

Certain EU leaders (Both Government and Opposition) seam to think its all right to ask us to vote again. I say NO! We had 55% turnout which is above average, we the people have spoken. The project must find another way to move forward.

If the government bows to pressure from France, Germany, Italy and others, I will not campaign for a Yes Vote, I infact will vote NO. If the EU is to be democratic then it should respect democratic outcomes.

People who read this blog know I am very pro-EU, infact nearly a Euro-federalist, but at the same time I respect the vote of the people. We in Ireland were in a unique position to vote on this treaty and we were not voting on it for 500 million other people, we were voting to change a document that says how Ireland is governed, Bunreacht na hEireann which only affects 4 million or so people. I am still annoyed with this arguement.

I have a big issue which the claims of some members of the No side. Sinn Fein did not win this for them In fact most people I talked to were ignoring SF. The people that won it were Libertas on the right and Coir (not sure where they are) and the sociailists and anarchists (People's movement) on the left who ran a very good campaign and were out in Cork City every weekend trying to convince people while the Yes crowd were no were to be seen.

Anyway I think I've made my point and my dinner is burning!

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

Voting No? Then we could lose our commissioner next year!

Yes, thats right! Libertas is telling lies! According to Fine Gael TD Leo Varadkar

Under Lisbon, the European Commission will be reduced in size to 18 Commissioners from 2014 and all countries will rotate on and off the commission in strict equality. In short, each country will nominate a Commissioner for ten years out of every 15. In fact, there is even a clause in the Lisbon Treaty that would allow for all countries to continue to have a Commissioner indefinitely, should all countries want that to happen.

"However, if the Referendum is lost, the compromise agreed at Lisbon falls and the provisions of the Nice Treaty will apply. Under Nice, the Commission will be reduced to 26 or fewer members from the middle of next year


So how EU members states are there? 27. How many commissioners? 26. Chances are if we vote know, we will lose.

People forget that this was an issue under the Nice Treaty. We already accepted the fact that we will not always have a commissioner. Lisbon sets it out on a more equal basis!

Vote YES to retain our commissioner! (For another bit!)

Full Press Release

The "No Argument" I hate the most

Someone left a comment on "What Better Deal?", since deleted, using the argument I hate the most. The Argument in question is, that other countries are being denied the vote. That is only true in one country in my opinion and that is the United Kingdom where the Labour Government promised a referendum, but did not deliver. In every other country this is not the case. In fact national referendums are illegal in Germany so the argument goes no where. We have to hold a referendum due to the Crotty Case and the fact that membership is in our constitution. The argument goes nowhere and should not be entertained and personally I am fed up with it.

Of course the same commentator went on a about a "Christian Europe". Of course commenting on someone commenting on a Non-Christians claiming this is not going to win me over!

A short rant, but its my day off and don't want to harp on all day

Friday, June 06, 2008

What Better Deal?

This originally appear on the The Political Gay on GayCork.com

Sinn Fein's main message at this point in the Referendum campaign is to Vote No to get a "Better Deal". But what is this "Better Deal". According to a Sinn Fein Ad in today's Indo it is to:


* Secure a permanent Irish Commissioner
* Copper fasten key strategic veto's on public services, taxation and international trade
* Stop Irish rates of pay and conditions being undercut
* Protect neutrality and oppose the imposition if increased military spending
* Stop using taxpayers' money to fund nuclear power
* Main the absolute right of Irish citizens to have the final say in any significant changes to EU treaties
So SF give 6 things and none of them can be done. People forget that this is Plan B. Plan A was the European Constitution. There is no "Better Deal"! But lets look at what SF are looking for?


1. Secure a permanent Irish Commissioner
We voted to get rid of this under the Nice Treaty. This is not an issue with Lisbon, we as voters have already accepted this.

2. Copper fasten key strategic veto's on public services, taxation and international trade
The veto is retained on the second two and the first does not come under a competence of the EU, so a non-isue with this treaty.

3. Stop Irish rates of pay and conditions being undercut
This arrives from an EU Directive already in place about foreign Sub Contractors. Our Government has already agreed to this and is due to be implemented soon here. Voting No to Lisbon will not change this.

4. Protect neutrality and oppose the imposition if increased military spending
We ain't Neutral, we are non-aligned. No Neutral country would allow another have a veto over its use of military (Five countries have this power over Ireland). Also Neutral states, proper ones like Sweden and Switzerland, have large well equipped armies capable of defending the state. Our Defence Force does need investment! I dealt with the question of Irish Neutrality here

5. Stop using taxpayers' money to fund nuclear power
Good old EURATOM makes an appearance at number 5. We signed up to this, again we cant change it!

6. Main the absolute right of Irish citizens to have the final say in any significant changes to EU treaties
We will have this right whether we Vote Yes or No. As all states will have to ratify future treaty changes in accordance to national procedures. In our case a referendum!

As you can see all 6 are either impossible to achieve or already there. So what is the "Better Deal"? The Lisbon Treaty


Vote Yes on June 12th

Wednesday, June 04, 2008

The Myths of the "No Side"

I was out canvassing again on Friday after work and I again I am amazed at the number of people who are falling for the number of myths being propagated by the No side. I have also been approached a lot in social situations to what way I am voting and that as people know I am involved in politics, and again a lot of myths prop up in this and it is a lot easier to correct them in a social environment them when canvassing. Here are some I have come up against with the reality

1. The Treaty will Raise Taxes

Contrary to what some would have us believe, the Reform Treaty does not provide a mechanism that will force Ireland to abandon its unique tax regime. This Treaty does not bring tax policy within the competence of the EU. This Treaty clarifies what areas the EU can legislate on, and tax is not one of them. Ireland retains control of its own tax policy and its own tax rates.

Under the new Treaty we will retain our veto on an EU-wide tax. There is no reference in the Treaty to a common tax policy whatsoever. The No side are deliberately misleading the public, alleging that the Reform Treaty will undermine our corporate tax rate of 12.5%. This is simply untrue. Ireland's veto on tax harmonisation is a sound legal instrument that cannot be lost unless our Government were to take a considered decision to do away with it. This is unlikely.

A Commission proposal for a "Common Co-ordinated Corporation Tax Base" is under discussion. The objective of this is to provide that, for the purposes of taxation, all Member States would use a common system of defining the tax base, but not the rates of tax. A number of Member States, including Ireland, have already made it clear that they will not agree to this. This proposal will not succeed.

2. A European Super-State is Planned

There is no evidence on reading this Treaty that a super-state is being created. Rather it is a sensible adjustment and improvement to how the current EU institutions work, aimed at making the EU function better now that it has 27 Member States, as opposed to the 15 Members which comprised the EU 5 years ago.

It has been stated by No campaigners that the Treaty is a grab for power by Brussels at the expense of Member States such as Ireland. They claim that the EU is taking control of more and more policy areas. In fact the opposite is the case. For the first time the Treaty sets out exactly what the EU has responsibility for and limits the EU to those areas. Where the EU has no responsibility, it cannot interfere. Thus for the first time ever, this Treaty sets out very clearly the areas where Member States such as Ireland are to share power with the EU and in all other areas the EU cannot interfere. This is a progressive step.

3. It's the Last Time we Will be Consulted with a Referendum

This is a myth being propagated by the No side. Some opponents claim that this is a "self-amending Treaty". This is utterly untrue. Ireland must, by virtue of its constitution, consult the people by means of a referendum when ratifying any Treaty. The Reform Treaty does not, in any way, fetter this obligation. The Treaty does provide for a simplified amending process for future Treaties but states categorically in the revised Article 33: "The amendments shall enter force after being ratified by all the member States in accordance with their respective constitutional requirements." In other words, no changes can take place unless there is a referendum in Ireland, which is the usual procedure. Thus the myth that there will be no further referenda can by exposed for what it is.

4. Immigration Will Be Rife

The myth is also being put out that this Referendum will lead to mass immigration to Ireland, putting huge pressure on our employment levels as well as on our social welfare system. Again this is nonsense. Ireland, when signing up to the Treaty of Rome in 1973 agreed to the Free Movement of Workers, a principle that is a cornerstone of the EU. It has allowed Irish people to live and work all over Europe and has provided us with Latvian, German, Polish, French and other workers in this country. This has been good for Irish people and good for our economy. Immigrants from other Member States come to Ireland because there are job opportunities. If there were none, they would not come. The Reform Treaty adds absolutely NOTHING new in relation to EU immigrants coming into this country. We can guarantee that NOT ONE additional immigrant will enter this country as a result of this Treaty. It is a phoney argument created by scaremongers.

5. The EU Will Start to Cost Us Money

We have received billions of euros from Brussels over the years, and thanks to our membership we enjoyed an astonishing rate of economic development. We will continue to receive EU funding, through CAP. We will in future receive less in terms of EU Cohesion Funds than we have up to now, simply because the aid we received up to now has been successfully used by Irish people to expand our economy: its purpose has been achieved and it is now our turn to support others as we have been supported.

Membership of the EU continues to provide us with huge financial benefits. It is not just about the direct payments or the contributions to the NDP. The biggest financial gains are the indirect ones - the markets and opportunities provided by the internal market have given us more and will continue to give us more than we ever received in direct grants.

6. This is Just an EU Constitution by Another Name

Yes, this is similar to the EU Constitution. But what have been removed are those elements that made that document a "constitution" rather than a Treaty, those elements that certain member-states were uncomfortable with, such as giving status to the EU flag. We should vote on the substantive issues, not on words such as Treaty and Constitution - the EU as a project is unprecedented, and so labels like Treaty and Constitution really don't do justice to the unique institutional arrangements that these 27 countries have put in place.

Nothing is being foisted on anyone. We are debating this right now, which goes to show that there is a healthy open, public, democratic debate being held concerning the Treaty. It is ironic that spokespeople for the various "no" campaigns are all over the radio and other media telling us that there is no debate, that this Treaty is being sneaked through. In fact, it has been the subject of public debate and media comment since the Convention on the Future of Europe was first set up.

7. Other Countries are not having Referenda, so we should Vote No

We do not get to tell other countries, other nations, how they go about ratifying Treaties, whether they are EU Treaties or any other international Treaty. Even the most committed federalist would agree that how other countries decide on whether they sign up or not cannot be dictated by Brussels or by any other member state. No member state gets to tell any other member state what means they should use for ratification. That is basic international law, and basic common sense.

All of these other Member States are fully functioning democracies - the governments are accountable through the parliament. Just because they don't have a referendum doesn't make them undemocratic. Their governments are elected by the people and accountable to the people. The notion that our process of ratification is somehow more democratic than parliamentary ratification in a representative democracy is misguided arrogance. Referenda themselves are even unconstitutional in some other EU countries.

If you really have the interests of other Europeans at heart, you should support this Treaty.

8. The Treaty is Bad for Farmers


One point that is being mischievously propagated by the NO Campaigners is that this Treaty will cause hardship for farmers and will diminish the role of rural communities. Again this is a non-issue. This Treaty has absolutely NO impact on the Common Agricultural Policy, other than in one way, which we believe to be a positive one. Article 36 of the Reform Treaty, amending the Treaty of Rome, will change the way in which voting takes place in relation to agriculture and the fisheries.
For the first time, the directly elected European Parliament, as well as the Council of Agriculture Ministers, will vote on issues relating to agriculture. This will be of huge benefit to Irish farmers, as their MEPs will have a direct say. For the first time you will be in a position to lobby and influence your MEPs on matters of agricultural policy, not simply the Minister for Agriculture. In Irish terms, rather than depending on Minister Mary Coughlan to argue your corner, you will now have Mairead McGuinness and Avril Doyle, both members of the European Parliament's agricultural committee, influencing the direction of EU agricultural policy. We believe this is a step forward. Both the ICMSA and the IFA are supporting the treaty so it cannot be bad for farmers.

9. It will lead to the Introduction of Abortion and Stem Cell Research

The opposite is the case. For the first time, the competences of the Union are set out in the Treaty. Health policy is strictly deemed to be a competence of each Member State and not a competence of the Union. Therefore abortion and such issues are clearly recognised as issues not within the scope of the EU.

Anti-European campaigners try to terrify us by claiming that abortion and stem cell research will be foisted upon us. Nothing could be further from the truth. I can say clearly, that for the first time EVER, the Treaty sets out, and defines exactly the areas in which the EU can have a say. These areas include competition regulation, commercial policy, transport, agriculture and so on. Nowhere in this or any other Treaty does the EU claim any right to legislate on domestic social issues. This Treaty sets this out in a clearer fashion than any other Treaty. Therefore our own social and moral issues are afforded greater protection by this Treaty than any other. We should be glad of this.

10. We will be Forced to join a European Army

This is untrue. The new arrangements for cooperation in the areas of security and defence fully respect the neutral position of Ireland and other Member States. Ireland will not be subject to a mutual defence clause. European military activity is directed at peacekeeping and crisis intervention. Participation is at the option of each Member State, not obligatory. While we have and will continue to participate in peace keeping missions we do so on a case by case basis and subject to our Triple Lock principle - requiring the support of Government, Parliament and a United Nations mandate.

"NO" campaigners have been forecasting the end of Irish neutrality for 36 years: they have always been wrong and still are.

I remember the posters for the referendum on Amsterdam claiming the "End of Neutrality". the posters are still there.

11. Vote No to Punish the Government

Many people want to vote No to punish the Government. We are all fed up with our creaking health service, our inadequate education system and the gross mismanagement of the economy. However, we must hold fire. Your chance will come to punish the FF cowboys in the Local and European elections in 2009. Punish them where it hurts - in an election that judges their public representatives and their policies on their diabolical record in Government. Punish the Government in the elections in 2009. Don't punish yourselves and our country in the Referendum. Hold your fire and do the right thing in the Referendum on the Reform Treaty - Vote Yes.

12. Privatisation of Health and Education
This one is thanks to Cork City Councillor, Mick Barry of the Socialist Party

The Treaty sets out the competences of the and states in what way it can act. "education, youth, sport and vocational training" come under the heading of a "Supporting competence" which means the "Union can carry out actions to support, coordinate or supplement Member States' actions." which means it cannot lead to privatisation.

Health remains a national competence and so anything in relation to privatisation of Health Services remains with our nationally elected Government.

13. The State can take away your Children.
My sister was told this one at our door! She of course did not believe the No Campaigner

This one is beyond belief, Social Policy is only a shared competence as defined by the treaty which are not substantial changed by the Treaty of Lisbon which will add the following to the definition

"In defining and implementing its policies and actions, the Union shall take into account requirements linked to the promotion of a high level of employment, the guarantee of adequate social protection, the fight against social exclusion, and a high level of education, training and protection of human health." and "In defining and implementing its policies and activities, the Union shall aim to combat discrimination based on sex, racial or ethnic origin, religion or belief, disability, age or sexual orientation.". Nothing there about taking children away. Again that remains a national competence and if it comes in, it will be by our National Government and not the EU.


Some of these are taken from Heart-Of-Europe, but I have come up against them all and more!

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

Lisbon Treaty, State of Play, May 28th

Germany is the latest country to approve the Treaty. Ratification is till a bit away due to a court challenge. 14 countries have approved the treaty and of them 5 countries have fully ratified the treaty. Still a bit to go, but we are pass the halfway mark. Will Ireland bring it to a halt? or will it be the courts in Germany and the Czech Republic?

Austria - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 24/04/2008

Belgium - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Has passed the Senate (6th March) and the Chamber of Representatives (10th April). The treaty still has to pass the Brussels Regional Parliament, Flemish Parliament, Walloon Parliament, French Community Parliament and the German-speaking Community Parliament all due Mid-July

Bulgaria - Parliamentary Vote. Approved 21/3/2008

Cyprus - Parliamentary Vote.

Czech Republic - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. The Czech Senate decided to postpone the vote on the treaty and asked the constitutional court for its opinion on the treaty to see whether it is in line with Czech law
Denmark - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 24/04/2008

Estonia - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Vote due in May.

Finland - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in the Autumn.

France - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/02/2008

Germany - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 23/05/08 There is also a pending case before the Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe which must be completed before the President will sign off on the treaty.

Greece - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in Spring.

Hungary - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 17/12/2007

Republic of Ireland - Referendum. Referendum due on 12th June.

Italy - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. The vote will take place some time after the 29th of April.

Latvia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/05/2008

Lithuania - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/05/2008

Luxembourg - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Vote due in June.

Malta- Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 29/01/2008

Netherlands - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in the Tweede Kamer der Staten-Generaal (Second Chamber) in the June and the Eerste Kamer (First Chamber) in Autumn.

Poland - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 02/04/2008

Portugal - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 23/04/2008

Romania- Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 04/02/2008

Slovakia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 10/04/2008

Slovenia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 29/01/2008

Spain - Parliamentary Vote.

Sweden - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in November.

United Kingdom - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Passed the House of Commons (11th March). House of Lords to vote in April. Date TBD for Gibraltar Parliament.

------
Sources:
Europa
Wikipedia

Monday, May 26, 2008

Back on the Canvass

This was originally posted on The Political Gay on GayCork.com

Yes, I know I'm barely back a week and I am out canvassing. Nothing new there really.

I spent Friday evening and Saturday morning canvassing Mahon Point Shopping Centre, we then moved onto the City Centre for part of the afternoon (before the Match of course).

This is the first time I am canvassing (or even voting) in a constitutional referendum so it's all new and interesting for me.

So the reaction. On Friday the reaction to us (campaigning for a Yes Vote, juts in case you are unsure) was fairly balanced Yes/No wise, with the Yes being slightly ahead.

Saturday was quieter on reaction from both sides but most people seamed happy to take a leaflet on the Treaty.

What annoyed me was people who said they didn't know anything about the treaty yet refused to take some literature to actually read up about it.

What I don't get, is people who disagree with you who decide to rip up the leaflet in front of you. Its so heart breaking.... NOT. Get a life like, give it back if you don't want it, save the environment and all that!

The funniest thing that happened to me (Strange things always happen to me canvassing!) was that a woman passed me and then came back ( I didn't hand her a leaflet or attempt as I had been dealing with someone else) and told me I would regret supporting the treaty as under the Treaty of ROME, not Lisbon, that the EU would take over our land, I would be conscripted into an EU Army (I won't, I've done my service, if it was being brought in, which it is) and that the EU is being run by the Freemasons. I was like "huh?", No, I've read the Treaty's (Rome, Nice and Lisbon) and that does not come under them, as Rome was an economic treaty.

Another elderly gentleman gave out to me as the Treaty does not mention God. Why should it? It's an intergovernmental treaty!! Then he mentioned abortion, which is covered by a declaration under the Maastricht (or was it Amsterdam) Treaty, and the EU will not be telling us what to do on it!

Neutrality also came up on the canvass, a young man asked be it as a "straightforward Question" to which he wanted a "straightforward answer", he did ask in a nice way. I of course set the record straight for him. The triple lock will still be in place when the treaty passes (or fails). Also the Seville Declaration attached to the Nice Treaty safeguards our right not to take part in a common defence pact.

Right that's all for now. I am attending a Rally on the Lisbon Treaty on Thursday at 8pm in the Imperial Hotel and I will post my reaction to that also

Friday, May 09, 2008

Lisbon Treaty, State of Play, May 9th "Europe Day"

Latvia and Lithuania are the latest countries to ratify the treaty. While the Czech Republic has joined Germany in waiting for the courts to decided before they can offically sign off on the treaty.

Austria - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 24/04/2008

Belgium - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Has passed the Senate (6th March) and the Chamber of Representatives (10th April). The treaty still has to pass the Brussels Regional Parliament, Flemish Parliament, Walloon Parliament, French Community Parliament and the German-speaking Community Parliament all due Mid-July

Bulgaria - Parliamentary Vote. Approved 21/3/2008

Cyprus - Parliamentary Vote.

Czech Republic - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. The Czech Senate decided to postpone the vote on the treaty and asked the constitutional court for its opinion on the treaty to see whether it is in line with Czech law
Denmark - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 24/04/2008

Estonia - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Vote due in May.

Finland - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in the Autumn.

France - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/02/2008

Germany - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. The Bundestag is due to vote on the 25th of April and the Bundesrat is due to vote on the 23rd of May. There is also a pending case before the Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe which must be completed before the President will sign off on the treaty.

Greece - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in Spring.

Hungary - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 17/12/2007

Republic of Ireland - Referendum. Referendum due on 12th June.

Italy - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. The vote will take place some time after the 29th of April.

Latvia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/05/2008

Lithuania - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/05/2008

Luxembourg - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Vote due in June.

Malta- Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 29/01/2008

Netherlands - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in the Tweede Kamer der Staten-Generaal (Second Chamber) in the June and the Eerste Kamer (First Chamber) in Autumn.

Poland - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 02/04/2008

Portugal - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 23/04/2008

Romania- Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 04/02/2008

Slovakia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 10/04/2008

Slovenia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 29/01/2008

Spain - Parliamentary Vote.

Sweden - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in November.

United Kingdom - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Passed the House of Commons (11th March). House of Lords to vote in April. Date TBD for Gibraltar Parliament.

------
Sources:
Europa
Wikipedia

Tuesday, May 06, 2008

The Next Taoiseach of Ireland: Brian Cowen

Based on a post I orginally posted on The Political Gay over on GayCork

Tomorrow Brian Cowen will be elected Taoiseach of Ireland. The Big question will be the result of the reshuffle? Will Harney be replaced by Cannon? Who will get Finance? Who will be dropped and who will be promoted.

I have a feeling Lenihan will get Finance and Tániste. If that happens I think Coughlan could move to Justice. The poison chalice is the big Question though, if Hareny leaves Health who will take over? Cannon won't want it, if he has any sense. It will be interesting to have an Governemnt Minister in the Seanad though! It will increase its poistion within the political system.

Another question is will he drop any policies? will he try and renegiate the Programme for Government? I doubt on both of these. No Irish Government policy has major opposition in public opinion like 42 days and ID's in the UK. Of course the first month will be taken up with Lisbon, but that could be the waste of the Honeymoon period also.

What I want to know is will we see Civil Partnerships (Unions or whatever) under Cowen? Ahern was great on rhetoric but will Cowen take the action?

Random Facts:
He was born 10 January 1960 and was first elected in 1984 to represent constituency of Laois-Offaly. He has served in the following Ministries: Minister for Labour (1992–1993), Minister for Energy (1993), Minister for Transport, Energy & Communications (1993–1994), Minister for Health & Children (1997–2000), Minister for Foreign Affairs (2000–2004) and until tomorrow Minister of Finance.

He has wide ranging expeirence in a number of portfolios so has the potential to be a good Taoiseach.

The question is will he face the same problems has Gordon Brown? He is taking over from a popular Taoiseach, granted he has been dogged lately by the Tribunal, but he is popular in Ireland none the less.

He was not leader of the Party when elected. This isnt as big an issue as in the UK considering when we go to the polls you can vote for every party, as is the way with PRSTV. While in the UK you vote for one and thats the leader you expect. I dont see accusations of being 'unelected' being bandied about as much as they are with Brown.

Time will tell if he 'dithers' like Gordon. I dount he will though.

Of course he will always be BIFFO* to me dispite the fact he is Taoiseach!

*Note: I take BIFFO to mean "Big Ignorant F***er From Offaly" not "Big Intelligent Fellow From Offaly"

Friday, May 02, 2008

More bad news for Brown?

And also maybe bad news for the Treaty of Lisbon. ConservativeHome is reporting that Stuart Wheeler has gotten the Green Light for a judicial review on the UK Governments refusal to hold a Referendum on the Lisbon Treaty.

This will be an interesting case if it succeeds or fails. ConservativeHome have the background to the case here

UPDATE: Thanks to a commenter on Conservativehome I have got confirmation from Stuarts Website
2 May 10:00 a.m. - I am delighted to say that in his judgement delivered at the High Court this morning Mr Justice Owen decided that permission to apply for judicial review would be granted to me. In other words the result of the hearing last week is that we won. I expect to put more information on this website shortly.


Hasnt hit the main stream media yet!

Thursday, May 01, 2008

Europe: Let's Be At The Heart Of It

Well the Senior Fine Gael Party have a better slogan the YFG any way, so that has restored my belief in the party! Enda Kenny gave the following speech at the launch.

At the outset, I would like to say that I regard the forthcoming referendum as being of enormous importance for Ireland's future.

I am voting YES and asking Fine Gael supporters to do likewise because I firmly believe that Ireland's future success and prosperity depends on us remaining at the heart of an efficient, effective and democratic European Union.

I very much welcome the fact that we are holding a referendum on the Lisbon Treaty as it provides us with the opportunity to have a real debate about our place in Europe.

That's why this debate is fundamentally about our attitude to Europe. Do we want to be at the heart of it; or do we want to be isolated and irrelevant?

The Referendum is very important for the future of both Ireland and the European Union and I hope that we take it seriously and that the debate over the next 6 weeks is a comprehensive and honest one in which the maximum number of people are engaged.

It would be very easy for me, as Leader of Fine Gael, to sit back and allow this referendum to be dominated by domestic political issues. For example, many people are unhappy about the dramatic slowdown in the economy, the continuing crisis in the health service and the rise in violent crime and want to use the referendum to punish the Government. I am not prepared to allow that to happen. As in all previous European treaty referendums, my Party has campaigned vigorously for a 'Yes' vote. This we have done both in government and opposition as we regard EU membership as a cornerstone of Ireland's success.

That is why I am asking Fine Gael supporters in particular, and others who are unhappy with the performance of the Government, to hold their fire until next year's Local and European elections. I will put the national interest first and actively support the passing of the Lisbon Reform Treaty.

In fact, our campaign started some time ago and we are now well into our programme of over 30 public meetings throughout the country. What I have detected so far is that, while people are generally positively disposed towards Europe, there is much confusion about the Lisbon Treaty itself, and its implications. It is our responsibility and politicians to fill this information gap and I genuinely believe that Fine Gael's public meetings and the other elements of our campaign are helping this process.

Essentially, this Treaty's purpose is to reform the institutions and decision-making processes of the Union to cater for a population of 500 million in 27 member states and to prepare Europe for the many challenges it faces. These include the growing economic power of nations like China, Russia and India. Other global challenges like climate change, hunger and disease epidemics require Europe to speak with a coherent voice if our continent is to be effective in contributing to solutions to these problems.

I firmly believe that EU membership have been pivotal to Ireland's success story. It has ended our economic dependence on Britain and opened up new and fruitful markets for Irish products. When we couldn't afford to invest in our infrastructure, it was our European partners who stepped in. If they hadn't, the economic progress of the past 15 years would not have been possible.

It is beyond doubt that the significant inward investment the country has enjoyed has been stimulated by our place in Europe, Ireland being the only native English speaking country in the Eurozone.

At this time of economic uncertainty in Ireland, with growth forecasts falling, unemployment rapidly rising, tax revenues much lower that forecast, and a record budget deficit in prospect, it is more important than ever that Ireland strengthens its place in the European Union.

As the only country holding a referendum on the Lisbon Reform Treaty, we have a unique opportunity to reaffirm our commitment to the European process and to strengthen our place at the heart of the Union. A strong "Yes" vote will send a powerful message internationally that Ireland continues to be a central member of the evolving European process and that we are committed to the reforms necessary to equip the EU to meet the economic and political challenges it faces.

Apart from the indisputable economic benefits, we should also recognise that Europe continues to benefit Irish people in a wide range of areas. The fact is that most of our laws in the areas of the environmental protection, equality, employment protection, and consumer rights originated in European Union directives and regulation.

The questions we must ask ourselves when considering the Reform Treaty are:

- Do we believe that Ireland's future best interests lie in being part of a more effective and democratic, and less bureaucratic Europe?
- Do we recognise that a coherent European voice on the world stage will be a force for good?

I believe that most Irish people will answer 'Yes' to these questions and that is what this Treaty will achieve. It will reform the EU institutions to make them more effective and accountable and less bureaucratic. It will strengthen Europe's capacity to address global problems like poverty, aids and climate change. Critically, will also enshrine the fundamental rights of all European citizens in law.

The fact that Ireland is the only member state holding a referendum is both a privilege and a huge responsibility. We have a special responsibility to ensure that the debate over the coming months is an honest and rational one, based on the facts rather than on the many false and spurious arguments that have been promoted by anti-European groups in recent months.

Among the more bizarre claims I have come across include allegations that the Treaty will lead to the creation of a European army to which our young people will be conscripted; that the Treaty will pave the way for the legalisation of abortion; that the Treaty will threaten Ireland's corporate tax rate even though is clearly the fact that tax policy can only change with the unanimous agreement of all member state governments.

Possibly the most ridiculous claim I have heard so far is that the treaty will impose a limit on the size of Irish families, and I believe that a leaflet containing this nonsense has been circulated in Cork!

The truth is that these issues have nothing to do with the Treaty and it's time that those who are making these false claims admitted this.

One of the reasons why these false arguments have been spread has been the Government's prolonged dithering about the timing of the referendum and the delay in setting up Referendum Commission. This vacuum has been filled by misinformation and confusion as evidenced by the results of the recent opinion polls and surveys. These findings are a wake-up call that must be answered resoundingly. The incoming Taoiseach must take charge of and activate a Government campaign in support of the Treaty and I call on him to make this is immediate first priority.

I fully respect the right of people to oppose the treaty but I call on them to focus their arguments on the actual treaty provisions rather than on unrelated issues.

Such a debate must be aimed at ensuring that the Irish people are equipped with the true facts when they go to vote rather than adding to peoples' confusion by the spreading of misinformation.

I am confident that such a debate will result in the Irish people opting for solidarity and a future role of influence rather than isolation.



"Dithering" seams to have entered the political lexicon from the UK where Gordon Brown and his cabinet are regularly accused by the Conservatives for 'Dithering' on various issues. Nice to see Enda learning from fellow conservatives.

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

Lisbon Treaty: State of Play, April 30th

An update on its progress through Europe. The treaty has completed its passage in Austria, Denmark and Portugal. The List below has been update to reflect this. We are appraching the halfway mark as 11 of the 27 Member states have ratified the treaty.

Austria - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 24/04/2008

Belgium - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Has passed the Senate (6th March) and the Chamber of Representatives (10th April). The treaty still has to pass the Brussels Regional Parliament, Flemish Parliament, Walloon Parliament, French Community Parliament and the German-speaking Community Parliament all due Mid-July

Bulgaria - Parliamentary Vote. Approved 21/3/2008

Cyprus - Parliamentary Vote.

Czech Republic - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress.

Denmark - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 24/04/2008

Estonia - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Vote due in May.

Finland - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in the Autumn.

France - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 08/02/2008

Germany - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. The Bundestag is due to vote on the 25th of April and the Bundesrat is due to vote on the 23rd of May.

Greece - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in Spring.

Hungary - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 17/12/2007

Republic of Ireland - Referendum. Referendum due on 12th June.

Italy - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. The vote will take place some time after the 29th of April.

Latvia - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Vote due in April

Lithuania - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Vote due before May 9th.

Luxembourg - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Vote due in June.

Malta- Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 29/01/2008

Netherlands - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in the First chamber in the Autumn.

Poland - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 02/04/2008

Portugal - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 23/04/2008

Romania- Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 04/02/2008

Slovakia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 10/04/2008

Slovenia - Parliamentary Vote. Approved : 29/01/2008

Spain - Parliamentary Vote.

Sweden - Parliamentary Vote. Vote due in November.

United Kingdom - Parliamentary Vote. In Progress. Passed the House of Commons (11th March). House of Lords to vote in April. Date TBD for Gibraltar Parliament.

------
Sources:
Europa
Wikipedia

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Oireachtas Adjourned

On Monday I blogged about the upcoming EU Buisness in the Oireachtas this week. This has been changed due to the fact that both houses of the Oireachtas have been Adjourned till Thursday at 10:30 am due to the Death of fomer President Dr. Patrick J. Hillary.

The Dáil will now deal with the Twenty-Eighth Amendment of the Constitution Bill 2008 on Thursday. The Debate will finish at 3:30pm.

The Seanad will have no EU Business.

There will only be one Joint Committee on European Affairs meeting and this will go ahead as a public meeting on the Treaty of Lisbon, in Galway at 8:30pm at The Harbour Hotel.

Also the funeral of fomer President Dr. Patrick J. Hillary will take place today. The Requiem Mass will take place at noon at the Pro-Cathedral.

Tuesday, April 15, 2008

RTÉ subsite on Lisbon

RTÉ news have put together a good subsite on the Lisbon treaty here. Some interesting links including links to the text of treaty and all the headlines! Check it out.